Choosing the Right Vendor Management Tools: Features, Use Cases, and Evaluation Criteria
Consider this your comprehensive checklist
by Ashley Poynter
Content Manager
PaymentWorksChoosing the Right Vendor Management Tools: Features, Use Cases, and Evaluation Criteria
Managing vendors has become far more than a basic operational task, and it requires the right set of vendor management tools to do well. Why? Because it’s a strategic function, and the more you can remove manual labor from the process, the better. Vendor management underpins everything from compliance to reducing fraud risk and enables seamless payments.
But here’s the challenge: managing vendors manually (or with outdated technology) is a risk you can’t afford. That’s where tools come in. These platforms automate and centralize the way you onboard, maintain, and verify vendor relationships. When chosen wisely, they reduce friction, protect against risk, and improve your internal workflows across procurement, AP, and compliance teams.
In this guide, we’ll help you understand what modern vendor management tools should offer, how to evaluate them, and what to keep in mind as you make your decision.
Table of Contents
What Are Vendor Management Tools?
Key Features to Look for in Vendor Management Tools
Real-World Use Cases for Vendor Management Tools
How to Evaluate Vendor Management Tools
Measuring the Impact of Vendor Management Tools
Vendor Management Tools to Scale
Choose a Tool That Grows With You
Get Ready for Vendor Management Day 2025
Want Help Aligning Teams On Vendor Management Tools?
Interested in More Tips On Vendor Management Tools?
Want Personalized Guidance On Vendor Management Tools?
What Are Vendor Management Tools?
Let’s start with the basics.
Vendor management tools are platforms designed to help organizations streamline the entire vendor lifecycle and simplify everything from onboarding and compliance to ongoing updates and payment validation. Think of them as the single source of truth for all vendor-related data and activity.
Modern tools replace the traditional patchwork of spreadsheets, email threads, and manual checklists. Instead, they offer a centralized hub that simplifies:
- Vendor data collection
- Bank account and tax information validation
- Workflow routing and approvals
- Risk scoring and fraud detection
- Document management and compliance tracking
In short, these tools give your team more control, greater transparency, and reduced exposure to risk.
Key Features to Look for in Vendor Management Tools
Not all vendor management tools are created equal. To choose the right one, you need to focus on core features that support compliance, security, and long-term scalability.
Here are the features we believe are non-negotiable:
1. Automated onboarding workflows
Manual onboarding is time-consuming and error-prone. The right tool automates the onboarding journey with customizable workflows tailored to vendor types and risk profiles.
2. Secure bank account validation
One of the most common and costly fraud risks? Payments being rerouted to the wrong bank account. A strong tool integrates secure bank validation to ensure that the bank account on file belongs to the vendor requesting payment.
3. Audit trail and compliance tracking
Your next audit shouldn’t trigger a scramble. Vendor management tools should provide detailed audit trails, document tracking, and configurable compliance checkpoints to satisfy both internal policies and external regulations.
4. Granular access controls
Not everyone in your organization needs to see (or edit!) sensitive vendor data. Look for solutions with robust permission structures that safeguard sensitive info.
5. ERP and procurement system integrations
Seamless integration with your existing ERP, procurement, or AP systems is critical. You want a tool that reduces workload and makes your current tech stack work better.
6. Ongoing vendor maintenance
Vendors move, change bank accounts, and update contact info. A solid platform ensures this data stays current without constant manual intervention from your team.
Real-World Use Cases for Vendor Management Tools
One of the biggest mistakes organizations make is assuming that vendor management tools are only for large enterprises. The truth? These platforms serve critical roles across many industries and organization sizes.
Higher education & the public sector
Universities and public institutions often work with a broad array of vendor types, including research partners and local contractors. These organizations also face strict audit and compliance requirements. Automated tools help them maintain accurate records, automate due diligence, and ensure public funds are used responsibly.
Healthcare organizations
Hospitals and health systems manage massive vendor networks. And with the sensitive nature of healthcare data, secure onboarding and vendor verification are essential. These tools support HIPAA-aligned processes and reduce friction for busy procurement teams.
Enterprise procurement teams
Enterprises often have decentralized teams, global suppliers, and high transaction volumes. Vendor management tools bring visibility across departments, regions, and time zones. They also enforce compliance and reduce redundant work.
Finance & accounts payable
At the end of the day, it’s the AP team that bears the brunt of vendor errors and fraud. A strong tool reduces manual data entry, ensures payments are made accurately, and provides a defensible audit trail.
How to Evaluate Vendor Management Tools
Choosing the right solution is about aligning the tool with your real-world needs. Here’s a framework we recommend at PaymentWorks:
1. Map out pain points
Start here: identify where your current process is breaking down. Is it fraud risk? Delays in onboarding? Inaccurate vendor records? Get crystal clear on the problems you’re trying to solve.
2. Build a cross-functional evaluation team
Bring together voices from finance, IT, procurement, compliance, and even legal. A tool might look great to AP but cause roadblocks for IT. Collaboration ensures better long-term adoption.
3. Request tailored demos
Don’t settle for canned presentations. Ask vendors to demo workflows using real scenarios from your business. If they can’t customize the experience, that’s a red flag.
4. Ask about support and implementation
Even the best tool will fall flat if implementation drags or support is limited. Clarify timelines, resources required, and what post-go-live support really looks like.
5. Factor in risk reduction
A vendor management tool should reduce, not just manage, your risk. Ask about built-in fraud detection, automated validations, and real-time alerts. Compliance and security should be baked into the product.
Measuring the Impact of Vendor Management Tools
How do you know your investment is paying off?
It’s easy to focus on surface-level benefits, like onboarding vendors faster or reducing email back-and-forth. However, the real value of these tools lies in their ability to improve operational efficiency, reduce organizational risk, and enable smarter resource allocation.
To evaluate whether your tool is truly moving the needle, you need to track the right key performance indicators (KPIs). Here are some of the most meaningful metrics we recommend to our clients:
Time to onboard a new vendor
One of the clearest signs of improvement is a reduction in onboarding time. Where manual processes might take days or even weeks, automated workflows can cut that timeline down to hours. A faster onboarding process improves the vendor experience, gets services or products delivered sooner, and reduces internal bottlenecks.
The right vendor management tool:
- Accelerates project timelines
- Increases vendor satisfaction
- Reduces internal frustration across departments
Instances of fraud or payment error
This is a critical metric. One wrong payment, one fraudulent bank account update, and the consequences can be severe. You’re at risk for a slew of negative outcomes, from financial loss to reputational damage. A robust vendor management tool should help detect and prevent fraud through secure bank account validation and real-time risk monitoring.
The right vendor management tool:
- Protects your bottom line
- Keeps your finance and AP teams off the front page for the wrong reasons
- Demonstrates diligence to auditors and leadership
Percentage of vendor data auto-validated
Manual data entry is risky. It introduces errors, creates version control issues, and consumes valuable time. Vendor management tools should automate validation processes: checking tax IDs, verifying bank accounts, confirming business credentials, and more. The higher this percentage, the more resilient and accurate your vendor records become.
The right vendor management tool:
- Ensures data integrity
- Reduces the need for manual intervention
- Prevents downstream payment and compliance issues
Audit readiness scores or findings
For many organizations in higher education, healthcare, and the public sector, being audit-ready is non-negotiable. Vendor management tools should make it easy to pull reports, access documentation, and demonstrate compliance at a moment’s notice. Over time, you should see cleaner audits with fewer findings and less last-minute scrambling.
The right vendor management tool:
- Supports regulatory compliance
- Strengthens internal controls
- Reduces audit prep time significantly
Internal resource hours reallocated to strategic work
This is one of the more subtle (but powerful!) metrics. If your AP and procurement teams are spending less time chasing down W-9s, fixing bank errors, or redoing paperwork, they can shift their focus to higher-value tasks: supplier development, payment optimization, or strategic sourcing initiatives.
The right vendor management tool:
- Improves employee morale and retention
- Unlocks capacity for innovation and growth
- Demonstrates ROI in terms of human capital, not just software efficiency
A good vendor management tool makes your team’s life easier and protects your organization’s reputation, reduces risk exposure, and frees up time for the work that truly moves your business forward. Measuring these outcomes is essential to proving value, justifying spend, and continuously improving your vendor management strategy.
Vendor Management Tools to Scale
Once you’ve found the right platform, the next question is: how do we scale without losing control?
The answer lies in process and partnership.
- Diversify Use Cases: Expand beyond AP and procurement—think IT vendor onboarding, legal review workflows, or DEI tracking.
- Train and Enable Users: Don’t just roll out the tool. Offer workshops, create documentation, and build internal champions.
- Review and Optimize: Vendor management is dynamic. Regularly review workflows, integrations, and feature usage.
At PaymentWorks, we work with our customers long after implementation to ensure they’re not just using the platform but maximizing it.
Choose a Tool That Grows With You
Vendor management is no longer a background function. It touches compliance, security, operations, and finance. When done right, it can become a powerful asset to your organization.
Whether you’re a growing university, a complex health system, or a global enterprise, the right vendor management tools will simplify operations, reduce risk, and future-proof your processes.
Get Ready For Vendor Management Appreciation 2025
The Vendor Management Appreciation Day (#VMAD) celebration continues in 2025! And you should join us.
Why? Because there’s no expiration date on honoring one of the most important, under-recognized roles across industries: vendor management.
Join us in observing Vendor Management Appreciation Day (VMAD)! We’re gearing up for the 2025 celebration, and we want you to be a part of it!
VMAD is a new holiday geared toward unifying vendor management professionals and celebrating innovation in the field.
Moreover, we’ve released gifts each month to help you supercharge your vendor management efforts. Additionally, we’re planning some awesome events so everyone can connect and celebrate the important, strategic role of vendor management.
In the meantime, learn more here, and grab some free vendor management goodies.
Want Help Aligning Teams On Choosing the Right Vendor Management Tools?
Explore our blogs below. They’re filled with action items you can implement right away.
Nacha’s Upcoming Rule Change: What You Need to Know
The Case for Automating Third-Party Risk Management: Costs, Risks, and ROI
Cleaning Up Vendor Information Management for 2025
Vendor Verification: How NOT to Do it and What to Do Instead
Interested in More Tips On Choosing the Right Vendor Management Tools?
Want Personalized Guidance On Choosing the Right Vendor Management Tools?
